So I liked the idea of taking an expensive product. Breaking down the ingredients and finding better, faster, stronger, less pricey consumer purchasing or DIY options. If you are the kind of person who loves spoilers just scroll to the bottom for my final verdict.
At the request of a friend I am going to break out the ingredients for the It works Hair Skin and Nails.
As not to overwhelm you with the 28 ingredients at once I will group them into smaller more manageable categories. First off, the non - digestibles or fillers. Microcrystaline, Steraric Acid, Croscarmel lose and Cellulose.
Next I eliminate ingredients that provide taste or function (like keeping the pills from sticking to machinery) Peppermint oil, Stevia, Magnesium stearate and Silica.
Now I will weed out the Calcium ingredients Japanese Seaweed & Calcium carbonate. Not to say calcium isn't important to someones diet. It's just not something I am attributing long lush hair to.
The next category are the "boosters" or ingredients that increase circulation or provide anti oxidant properties. There are also anti inflammatory, and super-oxide listed in the ingredients. Grape Seed Extract, Goji, Haemoto Coccus, Melon pulp & Olive Fruit extract. Not that anti inflammatory or circulation enhancers aren't good for you. They are, and unlike the fillers they are possibly contributing to someones overall health which would improve the condition of someones hair skin and nails. However, not so much in the dramatic way we are looking for.
Next the "Deficiency" Vitamins. These are the vitamins in which "if" you have a deficiency it "may" cause hair loss dry skin and bad nails. The idea being the abundance of these items would then in theory strengthen hair. While that is a good theory sometimes enough of something is just that and more will not inflict any impact. I think perhaps they are just banking on a percentage of the population to be deficient in one or two of these. Then by filling the deficiency the person would in fact see dramatic improvement in their hair skin and nails. For what ever reason though they are in the supplement.
Vitamin B6 - - - - - - 200% DV
Biotin - - - - - - - - - - 1667% DV
Pantothenic Acid - - - 200% DV
Zinc - - - - - - - - - - - 133% DV
Maganese - - - - - - - 200% DV
A note on Biotin. Research on biotin is incomplete at best however deficiency is very uncommon (you body only requires 30mcg a day vs the 5000 mcg found in Hair Skin and Nails). Biotin has never been found to reach toxic levels in the body so no maximum recommended dose has ever been set. It is thought that an abundance of this vitamin will cause hair to grow faster skin to firm and nails to become stronger. Thus you have the mega dose found in this product.
So now that leaves us with 8 ingredients that should serve some direct function to providing longer hair, stronger nails and nicer skin outside of treating a vitamin deficiency.
Hair skin and nails has 2 collagen "enhancers" one is called
Gotu Kola Extract. Clinical test show that it helped produce collagen in wounds and promoted them to heal. It also is considered a viable treatment (although further research is needed) for treating circulation problems. It has also been linked to several side effects from nausea to in really high doses liver problems. The other collagen enhancer is
Vitamin C. Plain old Vitamin C is a key ingredient in collagen production and is pretty much impossible to over dose on, at least not in a way that would cause lasting damage.
The next 2 ingredients are the skin supporting antioxidants.
Alpha Lipoic Acid is an antioxidant that improves skin among many other common antioxidant benefits. It is actually thought to be very helpful for diabetics insulin and nerve pain. However it also comes with a slew of possible side effects ranging from rashes to interference with thyroid medication. The other antioxidant is
Vitamin E. Vitamin E has a long list of possible benefits ranging from better skin to repairing nerve damage after chemotherapy. All in all it is pretty much safe under the 400 IU a day line. At 400 mg it is a little more than half of the 400 IU dose. I would just be careful not to pair the It works Hair Skin and Nails with and additional Vitamin E supplement.
Besides the possible effects of 5000 mcg of Biotin the last 4 ingredients are likely to be the ones most responsible for hair growth, stronger nails and better skin.
Selenium - Is amazing for hair care especially when combined with Zinc. While too much could cause big problems enough is essential for healthy hair.
MSM - Like Biotin MSM has some lofty claims and mixed reviews. While inconclusive and understudied MSM is suppose to be magic ingredient for thick hair strong nails and gorgeous skin. It also, like biotin, doesn't seem to build up to toxic levels in the body so is considered safe to take well above the bodies required amount.
Fo Ti - This ingredient is the one that gives me the most pause. Although the research is inconclusive fo ti is thought to prevent early grey hairs and some hair loss. The bad news is that is has been linked to cause massive liver damage. The scary part is that because it is listed under the proprietary blend all we know for sure is that the dose is less than 400 mg. How much less is unknown.
Horsetail extract - Horsetail is one of those wonder herbs that has been used for over a century for everything from urinary tract infections to bed wetting. It also is believed to do wonders for your hair.
Wellness Mama even has a horsetail hair rinse recipe that looks like fun. While it should be avoided in some cases (pregnant nursing women or if you have kidney stones). It is pretty much safe to use.
So... is there something that will give similar if not better results for less than 55 cents a pill?
Verdict: YES

Spring valley Hair Skin and Nails ($11.95 for 120) or
Futurebiotics Hair Skin and Nails ($15.08 for 135) are both good. The only ingredient I wish they had in it is the MSM. Plain
MSM is $7.99 for 120 count. So if you paired the two pills you are still spending under $20.00 for double the number of caplets. It comes with all the "deficiency" hair loss vitamins and minis the Fo Ti.

The big winner I would have to say is
Country Life Maxi-Hair Plus. At 16.54 for a 120 count it hits the mark for price (about 14 cents a pill). It also comes with the full strength of biotin and the MSM. The only big difference is that it is missing the manganese. I wouldn't be too bothered by that though because unless you are deficient in manganese (which you are likely not to be) this will work just as well.
Also if you want to try out the biotin theory on it's own. 5000 mcg of plain
Biotin pills can be ordered for $5.99 (90 count).
There is also a
Caster Oil treatment that is suppose to be amazing. I use the Caster Oil in my shampoo bars but have yet to try it as a hair treatment.
*Disclaimer* I am sure there are other brands out there and if I come accost one or two I will do an update. I just want to note that my research for this post was done mostly on America Cancer Society and Web MD. This is not an effort to give medical advice or to treat anyone's condition. I am simply comparing one over the counter vitamin blend to another. I haven't done a full account of everything in the alternative hair skin and nails products. I was only looking at the noted ingredients found in Hair Skin and Nails by It works.